Our Victories in Britain
Palestinian Student, Dana Abu Qamar Wins Landmark Tribunal Victory to Overturn Home Office’s Visa Cancellation, Affirming Palestinians’ Right to Resistance Under International Law. Click to read more
In October 2024, Dana Abu Qamar has won her appeal at the First-tier Tribunal against the Home Office’s attempt to cancel her student visa in December 2023. This decision comes after court documents showed that then-Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick personally intervened in the matter, enquiring with the Home Office whether it would be “possible to revoke her student visa”. The decision affirms Palestinians’ right to resistance under international humanitarian law, ruling support does not constitute extremism; upholds right to free speech and declares revoking her visa was a violation of her human rights under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. It stands as a significant triumph for the Palestine solidarity movement, challenging the British government’s attempts to criminalise protestors and silence dissent. Read more
Palestinian Scholar Shahd Abusalama Secures Settlement Against Sheffield Hallam University after Zionist Attacks. Click to read more
In September 2024, Palestinian academic, activist, and artist Dr. Shahd Abusalama, born and raised in Jabalia refugee camp, has achieved a significant settlement against Sheffield Hallam University (SHU) following a prolonged and challenging battle. After her appointment as a lecturer in January 2022, Dr. Abusalama faced defamatory campaigns from Zionist organisations and endured multiple investigations. An independent report by Akua Reindorf KC cleared her of all wrongdoing. Despite this, SHU prepared damaging briefings and collaborated with The Jewish Chronicle (JC) to smear her reputation and leaking details to the JC and Members of Parliament, ultimately violating confidentiality agreements. This leak revealed details about Shahd’s departure and the new £8 billion campus at Brent Cross, “in the heart of north London’s Jewish community”, as reported by the JC, which SHU shamelessly used to enhance its image in the Jewish community.
UK Prosecutors Drop Case Against Academic After Being Referred to Prevent. Click to read more
In July 2024, Britain’s Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has dropped the case against academic Amira Abdelhamid. Her employers, the University of Portsmouth had referred her to the Prevent program following a series of her social media posts, eventually leading to several counter terrorism police raiding on her home, confiscating her electronic devices and violently arresting her. Accused of bringing the university’s name into disrepute and supporting a proscribed group, Amira faced severe repercussions based on unfounded allegations. The UN has criticised the Prevent program as racist, calling for its suspension. Read more
Former President of the NUS Shaima Dallali ends her legal battle against the students union. Click to read more
Shaima, a staunch anti-zionist student activist, was unfairly dismissed from her position as President of NUS in 2022 after a biased investigation. In the face of this attack to silence Palestinian rights advocates, we provided legal advice to Shaima during the proceedings. She is not the first Muslim and racialised student to have her social media monitored in an attempt to frame her as antisemitic. The NUS has now cleared her of all allegations, acknowledging she ‘is, and as President of NUS she was, entitled to hold protected beliefs’ including pro-Palestinian and anti-Zionist beliefs. Read more
Science Secretary withdraws allegations against members of the UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) for expressing solidarity with Palestinians and pays damages. Click to read more
Professor Kate Sang and Dr Kamna Patel of UKRI were baselessly accused by the Science Secretary Michelle Donelan of sharing ‘extremist views’ for reposting a Guardian article about the aftermath of 7 October and for expressing concern over Israel’s actions in Palestine on their social media, solely drawing from smears published by lobby group Policy Exchange. They reached out to the ELSC and we connected them with lawyers on the ground who helped them take legal action against the Science Secretary for her unfounded and outrageous allegations. In March 2024, UKRI has concluded they were not in breach of the terms of their appointment and Secretary Donelan apologised and withdrew her false allegations against the academics.
Jewish Chronicle apologises to Palestinian scholar for publicly smearing him. Click to read more
In December 2023, the Jewish Chronicle rectified the article that drummed up false allegations against Palestinian scholar Dr Nimer Sultany and were forced to apologise to him after he filed a complaint to the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) with the support of the ELSC. Read more
Campaigner cleared of allegations of antisemitism based on the harmful IHRA definition after a speech in solidarity with Palestine at a city council meeting. Click to read more
In February 2023, a campaigner was censored and silenced by the Sheffield City Council for showing solidarity with Palestine. The Sheffield City Council unfoundedly accused the campaigner of being antisemite, alleging that her speech in solidarity with the Palestinian people breached the IHRA definition of antisemitism, adopted by the City Council. But we pushed back and won. We sent a legal letter to Sheffield City Council, reminding them of their obligations to protect freedom of speech. As a result, the City Council not only confirmed that the campaigner’s statement was not antisemitic but added that the council did not adopt the IHRA definition in the first place. It placed a correction on its website, fully clearing the campaigner’s name. This helped create space in Sheffield for campaigners to continue to call for an end to the occupation, apartheid, and genocide in Palestine.
Trade union activist reinstated after being suspended for unfounded accusations of antisemitism. Click to read more
In November 2021, Victor, an advocate for Palestinian rights and trade union activist was suspended as a trade union representative for allegedly posting antisemitic comments online. The alleged incriminating messages were largely about criticism of the policies of the state of Israel by former Labour Party members and included a reference to Palestinian revolutionary and poet Ghassan Kanafani. In support of its decision to suspend Victor as senior representative, the union referred to an ‘expert opinion’ authored by a person known for his pro-Israel stance. After our lawyers rebutted the controversial opinion by submitting our own expert opinion, exposing the bias and proving that the allegations against our client were unfounded, we managed to get Victor reinstated and rehabilitate his reputation inside the respective trade union. After a significant period of suspension, following the internal hearing in September 2022, Victor was reinstated to his elected and appointed positions with immediate effect.
Palestinian scholar Shahd Abusalama reinstated following suspension and investigation due to smear campaign. Click to read more
Shahd Abusalama faced a smear campaign and had her teaching erroneously suspended by Sheffield Hallam University in January 2022, as a result of unfounded complaints filed against her. With legal support from the ELSC, and numerous organisations and individuals who collectively campaigned against this unjust treatment, Shahd’s teaching was restored and the investigation against her was dropped in February 2022. Read more.
Barrister critical of Zionism on personal social media channel cleared from allegations of antisemitism. Click to read more
In January 2021, a barrister was subjected to two complaints sent to two different bodies related to their profession, over their social media post which qualified Zionism as a form of racism and colonialism that has created an apartheid regime. The barrister also asserted that holding Zionist views was incompatible with anti-racism. Both complainants alleged that the post was offensive and amounted to antisemitism. The ELSC provided legal assistance during the investigations and mobilized experts and partner organisations who submitted letters in support of the barrister. Both the complaints were considered as baseless and the investigations were closed.
UK’s biggest pro-Israel outlet pressured to remove defamatory story on Palestinian activist. Click to read more
Omar Mofeed, General Secretary of the Arab Labour Group, was viciously smeared after the Jewish Chronicle (JC) published a defamation story about Omar full of inaccurate information and false allegations. With legal advice from the ELSC, Omar filed a complaint to the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) against the newspaper in July 2022. Omar successfully refuted the inaccuracies as the JC granted his request to remove the story permanently.
Media publication successfully publishes major editorial on Palestine. Click to read more
In preparation for potential backlash made in bad faith or legal threats, a UK antiracist online and print media publication looking to publish an editorial on Palestinian rights pre-emptively reached out to the ELSC in August 2022. The team provided expert advice and the outlet has since successfully launched its editorial with no issues.
Public employer reinstates student after walking back on rescinded offer for breach of IHRA definition of antisemitism. Click to read more
A student had been recruited by a public body in August 2021 but the job offer was subsequently rescinded because the employer deemed that some of their social media posts amounted to ‘unlawful antisemitism’ according to the examples provided by the IHRA definition of antisemitism. The posts expressed solidarity with the Palestinian people during the 2021 bombing of Gaza and criticism of Zionism. The ELSC argued that the dismissal was discriminatory and violated the student’s right to freedom of expression. As a result, the student was reappointed and fully remunerated, including for working time missed due to the revocation.
While on book tour, professor Somdeep Sen overcomes censorship attempt following defamatory allegations of antisemitism and use of the IHRA definition. Click to read more
In October 2021, Associate Professor at Roskilde University, Copenhagen, Dr. Somdeep Sen, was invited by the University of Glasgow to deliver a lecture about his new book “Decolonizing Palestine”. Prior to the event and following a complaint by the university’s Jewish society alleging antisemitism, the university required Dr. Sen to provide details of his talk ahead of time and warned him against speech that may breach UK anti-terrorism law or the IHRA definition of antisemitism. The ELSC advised the professor and worked with partners to submit letters of support raising concerns about academic freedom. Dr. Sen subsequently rejected the university’s invitation and the event took place at another location.
After investigation involving IHRA definition, dozens of antisemitism charges against academics advocating for Palestinian rights at the same university found unsubstantiated. Click to read more
In 2021, 15 university staff members were subjected to disciplinary investigations by their university in the span of only seven months. Anonymous complaints against them had been submitted, alleging that they had participated in antisemitic activity or shared antisemitic content online or in their academic literature. The complainants even used letters that some academics signed in support of fellow Palestinian rights defenders or merely liked or bookmarked content to back their claims of antisemitism. After a lengthy disciplinary process and with the support of the ELSC, the university cleared all academics of these allegations.
University finds no case after complaint filed against student who shared Human Rights Watch content on Israeli apartheid. Click to read more
In June 2021, a university received an anonymous complaint and opened an investigation into alleged antisemitism against a student who had posted on their social media a Human Rights Watch infographic about Israel’s system of apartheid in the West Bank. They referred to the latter as ‘ethnic cleansing’ and ‘reminiscent of South African apartheid’. Following legal support from the ELSC, the university found that there was no case to answer and dropped the investigation.
Antisemitism complaint against anti-racist and pro-Palestine student activist based on IHRA definition dismissed by university. Click to read more
In 2021, a university investigated a student activist for alleged antisemitism for attending a Black Lives Matter protest, reposted literature by a prominent Palestinian poet and written social media posts critical of the Israeli army. When the ELSC demonstrated that there was a pattern of ongoing harassment and defamation of the student by the complainants, due to their activism for Palestinian rights, the university dismissed the complaint.
Student activists successfully counter unfounded complaints of antisemitism after being placed under investigation by university using IHRA definition. Click to read more
In response to anonymous complaints, 5 students student activists were placed under investigation in April-May 2021 by their university for social media posts condemning Israel’s human rights abuses and Zionism, and supporting Palestinian rights. The complainants maintained that the posts breached the IHRA definition, therefore amounting to antisemitism, and claimed that this risked bringing the university into disrepute. The ELSC defended the students against the allegations and the university dismissed the complaints.
Academic fended off dismissal attempts following a smear campaign and accusations of breach of the IHRA definition by Campaign Against Antisemitism. Click to read more
At the beginning of 2021, an academic and human rights campaigner faced smears by Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA), a pro-Israel organisation which sent a complaint to the academic’s University for allegedly breaching the IHRA definition of antisemitism through the academic’s attendance at Palestinian rights protests. As a result of the ELSC’s legal support, the University eventually cleared the academic of the allegations, stating that the conduct in question constituted a ‘legitimate, legal and peaceful political protest, consistent with the University’s commitment to freedom of expression’.
After academic is publicly smeared based on lecture content and subjected to antisemitism complaint, university declares allegations unfounded. Click to read more
In 2019, a student recorded snippets of a lecture taught by an academic and took pictures of the lecture slides. These were then handed over to anti-Palestinian media platforms such as the Jewish Chronicle, which proceeded to smear the professor as antisemitic and supportive of terrorism by distorting the professor’s words. A complaint was lodged against the academic, which opened an investigation. The ELSC provided legal assistance and the academic was cleared of all false allegations.
Society retracts bogus claims of antisemitism against student campaigner for Palestinian rights maligned in lead-up to students’ union elections at Leeds University. Click to read more
In February 2020, a Palestinian student at Leeds University and activist for Palestinian rights ran for election to the Students Union (LUU). A few days before the vote, the Jewish Society, a student society in the LUU, circulated an email accusing the student of antisemitism and supporting terrorism. The email was sent to all student societies except for the Palestine Society. Although the Jewish Society failed to provide any evidence for its claims, the student still lost the endorsement of many student societies and the subsequent election. With the support of the ELSC, the student submitted a complaint and an open solidarity letter was widely endorsed and circulated. After an investigation, the LUU ordered the Jewish Society to retract its slanderous statement and ensure that the persons responsible step down from their positions in the Society.
For confidentiality reasons, many names of the individuals and entities involved in the above cases are not disclosed.
WILL YOU HELP US WIN MORE CASES?
Thank you @elsclegal for being on my side and supporting me legally throughout this fight. The victory is ours
Tweet from Shahd Abusalama, Palestinian activist, artist, PhD in the UK
@elsclegal network are brilliant. Includes UK country focus, defending Pal advocacy, supporting, advising & taking on cases of those in need.
Tweet from Artists for Palestine UK
If you want to be updated on our future victories and events, subscribe to our newsletter here and follow us on social media @elsclegal
If you require legal advice or support, or would like to report an incident, please do so here.
